Evenflo Shyft vs Doona Car Seat Stroller – Which One is The Winner?

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more›

Based on my detailed research and comparison of Evenflo Shyft and Doona car seat stroller, I have concluded that the Evenflo Shyft is the best option overall. It provides a great balance of functionality, comfort, and adaptability at a more affordable price point.

Type

2-in-1 Car Seat/Stroller

Integrated Car Seat/Stroller

Weight Limit

Up to 35 lbs

Up to 35 lbs/32″

Starting Weight

3 lbs

4 lbs

Safety

5-point harness

Side-impact protection

Foldability

One-hand fold

Instant fold

Adjustability

Handlebar, recline

Fixed handle, no recline

Surfaces

Various, large wheels

Smooth, small wheels

Accessories

Organizer, tray, shield, adapter, footmuff

Bag, cover, storage, sunshade, wheel covers

Price

More affordable

More expensive

Best For

Versatility and value

Ease of use, city living

Why You Should Trust Me?

You might wonder why you should listen to what I have to say about strollers. I’m Andjela, a special educator and rehabilitator. I care deeply about what’s best for kids, which is why I’ve spent days looking into the Evenflo Shyft and the Doona car seat strollers for you. I didn’t just read a few reviews; I went through forums, checked out Facebook, and watched a bunch of YouTube videos to get all the info I could. I wanted to make sure I’m giving you advice that’s really useful, based on lots of research and a big desire to help.

Table of content

Understanding Car Seat Stroller Combos
Evenflo Shyft Travel System Review
Doona Car Seat Stroller Review
Similarities and Differences
How To Choose Between Evenflo and Doona
Evenflo Shyft vs Doona Comparison
Final Verdict

Understanding Car Seat Stroller Combos

Before we start comparing, let’s clarify what a car seat stroller combo is. It’s basically a 2-in-1 solution that combines a detachable infant car seat with a matching stroller. This setup offers convenience and flexibility for parents who are often on the move. 

Why Should You Have One?

Let’s understand why having a car seat-stroller combo is a smart choice:

1. Easy to Use: Switch from driving to walking easily without waking up your baby.

2. Saves Money: Buying one combo is cheaper than buying a car seat and stroller separately.

3. Saves Space: One item for two big needs means less stuff to store.

4. Grows with Baby: Fits your baby as they get bigger, from newborn to toddler.


Evenflo Shyft Dualride Review 

What’s important to know about the Evenflo Shyft travel system:

It’s Two Essentials in One

What It Does: It combines a car seat and a stroller. After driving, you can quickly convert the car seat into a stroller without waking your baby.

Why It Matters: It saves space, time, and money. There is no need to buy a separate car seat and stroller.

Built with Safety in Mind

Features: Comes with a 5-point harness that’s easy to secure and adjust.

Benefit: Keeps your baby safe on the road and while strolling.

Easy to Use

How It Works: The stroller folds easily with one hand, making it compact to store or carry.

Practicality: Ideal for parents who often go out alone with their baby, ensuring you’re never left struggling to fold or unfold the stroller.

Designed for Comfort

Adjustability: The stroller seat reclines, and there’s a canopy to protect your baby from the sun.

Advantage: Whether napping or exploring the world around them, your baby stays comfortable.

Grows with Your Child

Capacity: It’s made for newborns up to babies weighing 35 lbs.

Consideration: Perfect for the first few years, after which you might need a stroller for a heavier child.

Evenflo Shyft Pros and Cons

Let’s understand the pros and cons of the Evenflo Shyft Dual ride:

Pros:

  • 2-in-1: Car seat and stroller combo.
  • Safe: Meets high safety standards.
  • Easy: One-hand fold system.
  • Comfortable: Adjustable seat and canopy.

Cons:

  • Weight Limit: Up to 35 lbs only.

Doona Car Seat Stroller In-Depth Review 

Now that we’ve learned about the Evenflo Shfyt DualRide, let’s learn about the Doona so we can make an informed decision later.

Simplicity and Innovation Combined

What It Offers: The Doona is a car seat that can easily transform into a stroller with a simple click. It’s a unique hybrid that saves you the trouble of carrying both a car seat and a stroller.

Why It’s Great: It eliminates the need for a separate car seat and stroller, making travel and transitions from car to walking quick and hassle-free.

Designed for Safety

Key Features: This product is designed to ensure the safety of your baby while in the car or out for a stroll. It meets safety standards and includes side-impact protection.

Peace of Mind: With its focus on safety, the Doona offers reassurance that your child is protected in all aspects of its use.

Unmatched Convenience

How It Simplifies Life: Transition from car seat to stroller in seconds without disturbing your baby; ideal for running errands, dropping off at daycare, or traveling.

Space-Saving: Its compact design is perfect for smaller vehicles and for storing at home when space is at a premium.

Comfort for Baby

Comfort Features: Includes a padded infant insert, adjustable canopy, and multiple recline positions to keep your baby always comfortable.

Advantages: These features ensure that the Doona is not just practical for parents but also a cozy, secure space for your baby.

Growth and Longevity

Usage: It is suitable from birth until your baby reaches 35 lbs or 32 inches in height, whichever comes first.

Consideration: While it offers excellent utility for newborns and infants, you will need to transition to a traditional stroller once your child outgrows it.

Doona Pros and Cons

Let’s understand the pros and cons of Doona:

Pros:

  • All-in-One: Transforms from car seat to stroller instantly.
  • Compact: Saves space and eliminates the need for multiple products.
  • Safety: Exceeds standard safety requirements.
  • Convenient: Perfect for quick trips and traveling.

Cons:

  • Short Lifespan: Suitable until baby reaches 35 lbs or 32 inches.

Similarities and Differences

To compare Doona vs Evenflo Shyft, it’s important to know their similarities and differences. Here’s a closer look:

Similarities:

Size: Both are designed to cater to a similar range in weight and height, accommodating babies from birth up to around 35 lbs or 32 inches tall. This makes them suitable for use during the infant stage up to early toddlerhood.

Safety Features: Each adheres to high safety standards, equipped with robust safety mechanisms such as secure harness systems and side-impact protection, ensuring your child’s well-being whether in the car or out for a stroll.

Differences:

Suitability for Newborns:

Evenflo Shyft: It can fit babies who weigh at least 3 pounds and are at least 15.7 inches tall.

Doona: It is suitable for babies from 4 lbs, without a specified start height, and focuses on a one-size-fits-all approach.

Additional Features:

 Evenflo Shyft: Emphasizes versatility with its 2-in-1 car seat and stroller combo, featuring an intuitive one-hand fold system for easy transitions.

 Doona: Stands out for its immediate transition from car seat to stroller, offering unparalleled convenience for quick trips and minimizing the gear needed for travel.


How to Choose Between Evenflo and Doona 

After exploring each product individually and examining their similarities and differences, we can now compare Evenflo and Doona to understand how to choose between them.

Evenflo Shyft vs Doona Comparison 

Specifications:

Let’s compare Evenflo Shyft Dualride vs Doona specs to help you choose the best option.

Key Takeaways:

  • Weight Range: Both the Evenflo Shyft and Doona can carry babies from newborns up to 35 lbs. However, the Shyft can carry babies from 3 lbs, while the Doona can carry babies from 4 lbs.
  • Height Limit: Both the Doona and Evenflo Shyft have a maximum height recommendation of 32 inches. However, the Evenflo Shyft provides specific guidance with a starting height of 15.7 inches.

Winner: Evenflo Shyft DualRide 

Considering the weight range and height recommendation, both Evenflo Shyft DualRide and Doona Car Seat & Stroller offer similar capabilities, but the Evenflo Shyft’s ability to accommodate newborns starting from 3 lbs, and its specific height guidance provides a slight edge for families with smaller infants. 

Evenflo vs Doona for Newborns and Bigger Kids

For newborns (especially those born prematurely or with low birth weight) and bigger kids, the Evenflo Shyft DualRide and the Doona car seat stroller combos offer distinct advantages and considerations:

Evenflo Shyft DualRide for Newborns and Bigger Kids

Newborns

Premature and Low Birth Weight Compatibility: The Shyft DualRide is rated for babies starting at 3 lbs. and 15.7″, making it a potentially better option for very small newborns or premature babies. This can be crucial for parents of babies who are born earlier than expected or below average in weight.

No-rethread Harness: The car seat comes with a no-rethread harness system which makes it easier to adjust as the baby grows. This is particularly helpful during the early months when growth is rapid. The harness system ensures that the car seat fits safely and comfortably with minimal hassle.

Bigger Kids:

Accommodation for Longer Torsos: The DualRide is designed to accommodate children with longer torsos better, as long as they are under 32″ in height. The extendable headrest beyond the shell means that as your child grows, you can adjust the seat for a better fit, offering more room and comfort for older infants.

Doona for Newborns and Bigger Kids

Newborns:

Starting Weight: The Doona is suitable for babies starting at 4 lbs., making it slightly less accommodating for very small newborns compared to the DualRide. However, it still serves well for most average-sized and slightly smaller newborns.

Harness Adjustments: It has a more traditional setup with 3 sets of harness slots that need to be manually rethreaded for growth. This could be slightly more cumbersome compared to the no-rethread system of the DualRide, especially in the early stages.

Bigger Kids:

Ease of Use: The Doona is noted for its fluid conversion from car seat to stroller, which could be a significant convenience factor as your child grows. The ability to swiftly switch modes without removing wheels or additional steps can make outings simpler.

Accessories and Comfort: With sophisticated accessories available, such as leather handle covers, bags, and covers, the Doona might offer a more customized and comfortable experience for both the child and the parents as the child grows.

To make it simpler:

For Newborns: The Evenflo Shyft DualRide might be the better option, especially for premature or very small newborns, due to its lower starting weight limit and no-rethread harness system for easier adjustments.

For Bigger Kids: The choice depends more on parental preferences for convenience and comfort features. The DualRide accommodates longer torsos better, while the Doona offers smoother transitions between modes and potentially more stylish accessories.

Winner: Evenflo Shyft DualRide

It offers better compatibility for newborns, especially premature or very small ones, with its lower starting weight limit and no-rethread harness system, ensuring a safer and more comfortable fit from the beginning.

Adjustability and Features

Alright, let’s explore the adjustability and features for Evenflo vs Doona.

Evenflo Shyft

Adjustability

  Handlebar: Adjustable to suit parents’ height.

  Seat Recline: Multiple recline positions for baby’s comfort.

  Harness: Easy-to-adjust harness system for growing babies.

Features:

  – Convertible seating options (stroller seat, carriage mode, and frame stroller).

  – Large storage basket.

  – Canopy for sun protection.

Doona

Adjustability:

  Handlebar Fixed height.

  Seat Recline: Not applicable; fixed design as a car seat.

  Harness: Integrated 5-point harness, adjustable for fit but limited compared to traditional strollers.

Features:

  – Car seat and stroller in one.

  – Small footprint, ideal for compact storage and travel.

  – Includes a sunshade.

Winner: Evenflo Shyft Dualride

 The Evenflo Shyft offers superior adjustability with its adjustable handlebar and multiple seat recline positions, along with additional features like convertible seating options, a large storage basket, and a canopy for sun protection, providing more versatility and comfort for both parents and babies compared to the fixed design and limited adjustability of the Doona.

Usage and Comfort

Usage across various surfaces and comfort for parents of different heights are vital factors. Here’s a focused look at these aspects for both strollers.

Evenflo Shyft

Surfaces: Evenflo Shyft stroller is designed to handle a variety of surfaces with ease. Its wheels are larger and can smoothly navigate over bumps, grass, and uneven pavement. This makes it suitable for both city walks and more adventurous outings.

Parent Comfort: The Shyft features an adjustable handlebar, which can be adapted to suit parents of different heights. This adjustability ensures that pushing the stroller is comfortable and ergonomic, reducing strain on the back and shoulders.

Doona Car Seat & Stroller

Surfaces: The Doona is excellent for quick transitions and urban environments, but it has smaller wheels. It’s best on smooth surfaces and can struggle with rougher terrain, such as gravel or uneven sidewalks.

Parent Comfort The Doona has a fixed handle height, designed to accommodate the average user. However, this lack of adjustability might not suit all parents, especially those significantly taller or shorter than average.

Winner: Evenflo Shyft Dualride

The Evenflo Shyft excels in usage across various surfaces with its larger wheels and offers superior parent comfort due to its adjustable handlebar, providing ergonomic support for parents of different heights, compared to the limited adaptability and smaller wheels of the Doona.

Switching Modes

Let’s dive into the specifics of how the Doona vs Evenflo make the switch between car seat and stroller modes. This will give you a clearer idea of what to expect from each, especially from the perspective of a parent looking for practicality and ease of use.

Evenflo Shyft DualRide

Mode Switching: The Evenflo Shyft DualRide is designed for easy transitions between a car seat carrier and a stroller, offering versatility for on-the-go parents.

Steps:

  1. Car Seat to Stroller: To switch from car seat to stroller mode, you need to detach the car seat from its base in your vehicle and attach it onto the stroller frame. The car seat clicks securely into the frame.

  2. Stroller to Car Seat: Press the release mechanism to detach the car seat from the stroller frame and then secure it back onto the car base with a simple click.

Ease of Use: The Shyft DualRide focuses on making transitions smooth with intuitive click-and-go attachments. It’s designed to be straightforward, minimizing fuss and effort.

Time Required: With a bit of practice, switching between the modes can be accomplished quickly, generally in less than a minute.

Doona Car Seat & Stroller

Mode Switching: The Doona seamlessly combines a car seat and stroller into one unit, eliminating the need to detach or reattach the car seat from a separate stroller frame.

Steps:

  1. Car Seat to Stroller: Convert from car seat to stroller by simply extending the wheels with a button located at the back of the seat, transforming it in one smooth motion.

  2. Stroller to Car Seat: Retract the wheels to revert back to car seat mode. The entire process is hassle-free and can be done while holding your baby.

Ease of Use: Doona excels in convenience, making it ideal for quick transitions. The integrated design means you can switch modes effortlessly, without disturbing your child.

Time Required: The transition is almost instantaneous, making it perfect for busy parents on the move.

Winner: Doona Car Seat & Stroller

The Doona offers unparalleled convenience with its seamless integration of car seat and stroller, allowing for instant mode switches without the need for detachment, making it ideal for busy parents seeking quick transitions and hassle-free usability, compared to the more traditional, albeit versatile, mode switching process of the Evenflo Shyft DualRide.

Folding

Folding a stroller with a fussy baby can be a hassle. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you choose:

Evenflo Shyft Dualride:

  • One-handed fold: Folds with just one hand, perfect for multitasking.
  • Stands on its own: No need to lean it against something, it stays upright when folded.
  • Locks shut: Keeps it closed to prevent accidental unfolding.
  • Bonus: Includes a carrying bag for easy transport.

Doona:

  • Super fast fold: Forget complex folds! Just click to detach the wheels and you’re ready to go.
  • Not completely flat: Doesn’t fold completely flat, but still convenient.

Choose your champion:

  • Evenflo Shyft: Ideal if you need a compact fold and can manage one-handed folding. Plus, it stands alone and locks for extra ease.
  • Doona: Perfect if super-fast folding and easy carrying are your priorities.

Winner: Evenflo Shyft Dualride

The Evenflo Shyft provides a more versatile folding option with its one-handed fold, standing capability, and locking feature, offering added convenience and stability for parents, compared to the faster but less flat-folding Doona.

Accessories

Evenflo Shyft Dualride Accessories

  • Parent Organizer: Attaches to the handle, providing easy access to drinks and essentials.
  • Child Tray: Clips on for snacks and drinks, making on-the-go feeding easier.
  • Weather Shield: Protects from rain and wind, ensuring comfort in all conditions.
  • Car Seat Adapter: Enables compatibility with select car seats, offering a seamless travel system transition.
  • Footmuff: Keeps your child warm during colder months, adding comfort.

Doona Car Seat Stroller Accessories

  • Essentials Bag: Attaches to the stroller, designed for quick access to baby essentials.
  • Rain Cover: Custom fit to protect against rain, maintaining dryness and comfort.
  • Snap-on Storage: Expands storage capacity for extra gear, perfect for longer outings.
  • Sunshade Extension: Increases shade area, protecting your baby from harmful sun exposure.
  • Wheel Covers: Prevents dirt from the wheels getting inside the car or home.

Winner: Tie

Both Evenflo Shyft DualRide and Doona Car Seat Stroller offer a range of accessories that significantly enhance functionality and convenience. Evenflo shines with its travel system adaptability and comfort additions, while Doona excels in compact, urban-friendly solutions. The best choice depends on your specific lifestyle needs.

Evenflo Shyft vs Doona Price Comparison 

Evenflo Shyft is like getting a really good deal. It’s not too pricey and you get a lot for what you pay: it’s flexible and has lots of cool stuff for both you and your baby. It’s kind of like getting a great package deal that lasts a long time.

Doona is more expensive, but it’s super handy, especially if you’re always on the go. It’s like paying extra for a VIP ticket because it makes life easier. You get a car seat and stroller all in one, which is awesome for city life or if you don’t want to carry around a bunch of baby gear.

Winner: Evenflo Shyft Dualride

The Evenflo Shyft offers a better value proposition with its affordability and versatility, making it a practical choice for those seeking more options and long-term savings. At the same time, the Doona, although more expensive, provides unparalleled convenience, particularly suitable for busy parents prioritizing ease of use.


Final Verdict: Which Car Seat Stroller Combo is The Best?

The Evenflo Shyft is the overall winner for its versatility, value, and adaptability, making it the perfect choice for parents seeking a comprehensive, long-term solution. It stands out in offering a blend of comfort, ease of use, and functionality at a reasonable price.

The Doona stands out for those prioritizing quick transitions and compact convenience, especially in urban settings or while traveling. It’s ideal for parents who value speed and simplicity, offering a unique, all-in-one car seat and stroller combo despite its higher cost.

FAQ: Evenflo Shyft Dualride vs Doona

Is Doona better than Evenflo for travel?

Yes, Doona’s compact, all-in-one design is particularly suited for travel, offering quick transitions and space-saving convenience.

Doona car seat stroller advantages:

All-in-one design for easy transition, compact for travel and storage, and designed with safety and convenience in mind.

Doona ease of use for busy parents:

Simplifies transitions between car and strolling, making it ideal for quick errands and travel, saving time and effort.

Evenflo Shyft user experiences:

Generally positive, with praises for its adaptability, ease of use, and comfort for both parents and child.

Evenflo Shyft adaptability features:

Offers adjustable handlebar, multiple seat recline positions, and convertible seating options, making it versatile for various needs.

Evenflo Shyft for city living:

Its adaptability and ease of navigation make it a good option for city dwellers, though the Doona might be preferred for those with strict space constraints.

AUTHOR

I'm Andjela Antic, co-founder of DreamBabyGear. I have a degree in special education and rehabilitation from the medical faculty, and I've been a registered nurse since high school. Using my medical and education background, I understand child development well. I choose high-quality baby gear carefully to support the best development and well-being of children.
Photo of author